Story of a Walking Stick

At our April Meeting, Ros Simmnet told the story of her unique walking stick. It belonged to her grandfather, Edwin Jenkins, his life began in Western Australia. As a young man, he carted timber as an occupation but later in life, the lure of Kalgoorlie and gold attracted him.

It was here he married and had three children. His training and occupation during this period of his life was in explosives being used in the gold mining exploration.

At the beginning of World War I, he was conscripted by the army to use his knowledge of explosives to build trenches in France. Here he was severely injured. His partner saved him, but he had a damaged leg and shrapnel in his chest. He was transported to England, where his leg was amputated below the knee.

Ultimately, he came back to Victoria for rehabilitation at Caulfield. A use of a duck-board and eventually a prosthetic leg aided him in walking.

A special seat walking stick was constructed for him to assist in not having to weight bear for long period of time.

Ros uses his special walking stick today.

A wonderful sideline to the story is that a medical doctor in England who treated Edwin in the war years met him again at Caulfield Rehabilitation Centre, he could not believe that Edwin had survived his injuries. 

Source: 2024-06 DTHS Newsletter

Harriett Clark

Compiled by Gina Pederick, Harriett's Great Great Great Granddaughter and direct female descendant. 

Early Years

Harriett Clark (aka Clarke) was born in 1809 in Hartford, Huntingdonshire, which was a rural county in south east England, now subsumed into Cambridgeshire. Her par- ents were Sophia Danger and James Clarke. 

James Clarke’s first marriage was to Jane Spencer on the 12 Oct 1784. Jane and James had six children between 1785 and 1797 but when Jane died in February 1798, only three children were surviving. 

James’ second marriage was to Sophia Danger, in All Saints church in Hartford on 5 November 1789. Sophia was about 22 years old and James was around 39. Sophia could not write and simply made her mark on the marriage registry; James signed his name. 

Sophia and James had eleven children between 1799 and 1824; Harriett who was their sixth child, was baptised in All Saints church in Hartford on 3 December 1809 along with her two older sisters Sarah and Maria, who had pre- viously been baptised - Maria in 1807 and Sarah in 1805. From the baptism records of their younger siblings, when such information started to be recorded, James’ occupation was listed alternately as Labourer and Maltster. 


First Marriage

On 22 Sept 1831, at age 22, Harriett was married to William Favell (aka Favill, Fabel) in All Saints church, Hartford, Huntingdonshire. Neither of them could write and so both signed the register with an X as their mark. They had three sons who were all baptised in Upton-cum-Coppingford: 
  • Burrows, baptised 2 Dec 1832 and named after William’s father 
  • Benjamin, baptised 15 Mar 1835 and possibly named after both Harriett’s and William’s brothers
  • James, baptised in 1840 and named after Harriett’s father 

The 1841 UK census shows them living in the parish of Coppingford, Huntingdonshire and William employed as an agricultural labourer. 

In 1843, William Favell died. It is not clear how Harriett managed to support herself and her three sons after the death of her husband. It is possible they went into Huntingdon Workhouse, but more research is required here. 

Second Marriage


Harriett’s second marriage was to William Bullen on 4 Feb 1849 at the church of St Peter & St Paul in Alconbury. Neither of them could write and so both signed the register with an X as their mark. 

William Bullen was a widower. He was married to his first wife, Hannah Powell in Woodwalton Huntingdon. Before Hannah died in late 1846, they had two children, 
  • George, baptised 28 Aug 1842 at the Church of St Andrew, Woodwalton
  • Mary Ann, baptised 4 May 1845 at the church of St Peter & St Paul, Alconbury 

Together, Harriett and William Bullen had one child, a daughter.
  • Sarah, baptised 6 May 1850 at the church of St Peter & St Paul, Alconbury 

The 1851 UK census, taken on the 30 March, shows the family living in the Parish of Alconbury Weston and 29 April 1840 in Woodwalton Huntingdon. 

William, Benjamin and James employed as farm laborers. Harriett’s eldest son, Burrows, was also in Alconbury Weston working for, and living with, a farmer called Richard Nicholls, who was also an overseer of the Parish. 

Huntingdon Workhouse


On the 21 May 1851, William and Harriett, along with their four youngest children James, George, Mary Ann and Sarah, were admitted to Huntingdon Workhouse1. The cause for them seeking relief was stated as “sickness of husband”. It is not known how long the family stayed in the workhouse, more research needs to be done here, but given what happens next, it is likely the family con- tinued to require Parish relief. 

In early 1852, the rate payers of Alconbury Weston Parish make a decision that would dramatically change the lives of Harriet and her family. They decided to pay for the cost of emigration for any people dependent on the Parish for poor relief, who were willing to emigrate. We might assume that, as dependents of the Parish, Harriett and William were encouraged to emigrate. 

Excerpt from St Peter & St Paul Alconbury Weston Vestry minute book - February 1852 Henry Kiddiford Chairman: 
It was resolved that the churchwardens and overseers shall and they are hereby directed to raise the sum of thirty pounds as a fund for defraying the expenses of the Emigration of poor persons having settlements in this Parish and being will- ing to emigrate to be paid out of the rates raised or to be paid out of the rates raised for the relief of the poor in this Parish and to be applied under such rules as regulations as the Commissioners for administering the Laws for the Relief of the Poor in England shall in that behalf direct. The above is a true extract from the vestry book of the Parish referred to in the annexe certificate. Jenkins Hughes – Minister, John Warsop – Churchwarden, James Clark, Robert Nicholls – Overseers, Present Parishioners Witness – Anthony Clark, William Wright, Thomas Chapman, Thomas Bullen, Henry Kiddiford 

Colonial Land Emigration Commissioners were travel- ling through rural parts of England, Ireland and Scotland to encourage agricultural labourers to emigrate to Australia. The Victorian gold rush meant that many farm labourers had gone to the diggings and there was concern in the Colony that the crops would not be harvested. We can surmise that such Commissioners went to Huntingdonshire to attract farm laborers and were happy to take suitable poor families off the hands of the Parish. 

Things moved quickly and in June 1852 the Bullen fam- ily took assisted passage to Melbourne on the “Wanata”. Harriett and William travelled with the four younger children, James (11), George (10), Mary Anne (6), and Sarah (2), leaving behind Harriett’s eldest sons Burrows (19) and Benjamin (17). 

Burrows remained working as an agricultural labourer but on 17 October 1853, he was charged with stealing two half sovereigns and one canvas purse and sentenced to three months hard labour in Huntingdon Gaol. To date, no further records of Burrows Favell have been found. 

The UK census of 1861 shows Benjamin Favel living in Coppingford, Huntingdonshire, married to Mary-Anne Turner and working as an agricultural labourer. They had two children Matilda (7) and Charles (3), and records on Ancestry show living descendants. 

Wanata & the Ireland Family


The Bullen family departed Liverpool on the 19 June 1852, it’s worth noting that Harriett’s son, James Favell, was on the passenger list as James Bullen. On board was another family from Alconbury Weston, Hannah and John Ireland and their three children John (9), Mary Eliza (4) and Elijah (2). It is very likely the Ireland family was also supported by the Parish to emigrate, but more research is needed to verify this. 

Fifteen weeks later, on the 4 October 1852, they finally disembarked in Melbourne, but by all accounts, it would have been a difficult passage, and in fact conditions on the “Wanata” and other similar ships resulted in a par- liamentary enquiry. Many immigrants were already ill when they embarked, most were crowded into two levels below the main deck, and 33 children died during the voyage. “The suet provided on board proved to be so bad, as to cause its condemnation; and a still more serious evil was discovered in the badness of the water, a very large proportion of which was quite unfit for use, being full of a slimy gelatinous substance, resembling frog-spawn.” 

On top of that, the Commissioners, at the request of persons who were acquainted with the Australian Colonies, relaxed the regulation with respect to the number of children conveyed by their vessels; they agreed to take families, including a large number of chil- dren, under the belief that such persons would be least likely to resort to the gold diggings. 

State Library Victoria’s research department has made a search of the contemporary newspaper reports of the arrival of the “Wantana”. Its findings are as follows: 
On September 1852, the ship “Wanata” arrived in the Bay and anchored off Gelibrand Point (near Williamstown), with 796 government emigrants aboard. She had left Liverpool on June 19th with 820 emigrants. Thirty-nine of these died during the voyage. Of these thirty-nine, thirty-three were chil-dren. The discrepancy in the total is most probably explained by births during the voyage. The six adults died as follows – one from apoplexy, one from consumption and four from fever (probably typhoid fever). Dr Thompson was the super- intending surgeon on the ship, and Dr Dobbin was his assistant. Dr Hunt, the Health Officer of the port, visited the ship and ordered her to quarantine offshore between Brighton and St Kilda. The schooner, “Apollo”, was stationed nearby as a guard ship to prevent passengers from escaping from the “Wanata” until the quarantine restrictions were lifted by the authorities. It was proposed to release the ship from quarantine after a week had passed but, on September 23rd, a new case of fever was reported. All the sick passengers were then transferred to the schooner “Fanny”, which lay nearby, and this ship (the “Fanny”) was then also placed in quarantine. On October 4th, the “Wanata” was allowed to leave the quanartine (sic “quarantine”) area and join the other ships in the Bay, and arrangements were made for the migrants to disembark. 

An investigation into the deaths on board the “Wanata”, and three other large vessels that travelled to Australia around the same time, recommended that such large vessels no longer be used to transport immigrants because of the high mortality rates. 

With 33 children dying on the voyage, we can imagine Harriett and William would have been very concerned for the lives of their children. 

Bulleen and Beyond


The “Wanata” passenger list shows that on arrival William Bullen was to be engaged by Richard Adams in Bulleen for 6 months. The pay was £80 with rations. John Ireland was also to be engaged in Bulleen to Mr W Cook for £65 with rations for 12 months. The thick bush and hilly terrain of Bulleen must have been a shock for the families, who had only lived in the flat open, marshy countryside of Huntingdonshire. As the years went by, most of the family remained in the Bulleen / East Doncaster area. On the whole, they prospered and were able to purchase land and develop farms and orchards. 

Harriett died on 11 December 1868, sixteen years after her arrival in Australia. Her death certificate states she suffered “neuralgic affliction of the left side of the head” and had been unwell for 10 weeks before she died. She was buried in Waldau Cemetery on the 15 December. She was 62 years old. Like many in the area at this time, her death was registered by Max Schramm, whose cottage is now located next to Waldau Cemetery. 

Death Certificate Schedule B in the District of Doncaster in the Colony of Victoria Registered by Max Schramm No.56. Died: Eleventh December 1868 Doncaster.  Name: Harriet Cullen, Female 62.  Cause: Neuralgic affliction of the left side of the head.  Duration: 10 weeks. Medical Attendant: William Buchanan, Surgeon. Last Seen: Ninth December 1868. Father: John Clarke, Laborer.  Mother: Sophia Clarke.  8588. Informant: William Mullen (his mark), Farmer, Husband, Doncaster. Deputy Registrar: Max Scramm. Date: Twelfth December 1868. Where Registered: Doncaster  Buried: Fourteenth December 1868. Waldau Cemetery.   Undertaker: Valentin Gunther. Minister: G J? Armstrong. Witnesses: C? G? Laybridge?, Valentin Gunther, Joseph Pickering. Born: Harford, Huntingdonshire, England. In Australia for: 16 years in Victoria. Married:  Hawkenburg, Huntingdonshire, England. Age. Married: 42 years. Spouse: William Bullen. Issue: Sarah, nineteen years


Thirty-nine years after his arrival in Australia, William Bullen died on 21 September 1891 at Victoria Barracks in South Melbourne, where he was living with his daughter, Mary Ann and her husband John. He is buried in Box Hill cemetery, sharing a grave with his son George and daughter-in-law, Mary. 

James Favell married Mary Ryan, and they had one son. James died in 1891 in Beechworth, and records on Ancestry show living descendants. 

The Bullen and Ireland families remained connected and on the 22 May 1867 George Bullen and Mary Eliza Ireland married. They remained in East Doncaster and over the next 26 years had fourteen children. 

George died in 1907 and is buried in Box Hill cemetery sharing a grave with his wife and father. Records on Ancestry show living descendants. 

In 1872, Mary Ann Bullen married John Kirkpatrick, who was a Police Officer. They had seven children and records on Ancestry show living descendants. Mary Ann died in 1913 and is buried in Box Hill cemetery sharing a grave with her husband, John. 

Sarah Bullen married John Mathews on 1 January 1867, they remained in East Doncaster where they had a small farm. They had 13 children and many living descend- ants. Sarah died in 1907 and is buried in Box Hill cem- etery sharing a grave with her husband John. Two of their sons, Jim and Charlie fought in WW1. 

It cannot be overstated that the success of Harriett and William and their descendants was at the expense of the Wurundjeri people, who are the Traditional Owners of the land and who, for thousands of years nurtured and protected the land and its creation stories, and in return, enjoyed the highest standards of living, health and wellbeing. 

In 1840, the Wurundjeri people requested Bolin Bolin Billabong in Bulleen be reserved for their use as it was an important living and eel fishing area. It remained an important living area and visiting place for Wurundjeri people returning from lyrebird hunting in the Yarra Ranges into the 1850s. Eventually, Wurundjeri people and members from other Kulin (Victorian) tribes who were forcibly displaced from their traditional lands were taken to Coranderrk Aboriginal Station. 

Established in 1863, Coranderrk was located on the land of the Wurundjeri-balluk clan (William Barak’s clan). The Wurundjeri people and all First Nations people in Australia still suffer the effects of this devastating land dispossession, violence and racism. 

References: 
2. https://parlipapers-proquest- com.ezproxy.slv.vic.gov.au/parlipa- pers/result/pqpdocumentview?accountid=13905&groupid=9749 7&pgId=348fb0cd-28af-456e-b15e-c1feeebc7081#0 - page 4   (Dead Link Dec2025)

Source: 2023-12 DTHS Newsletter

Stone

During the Society’s discussions with Manningham City Council in planning the new building for our museum complex we put forward the idea of using the stone from the existing toilet facilities as a feature in the new building. It is proposed to use it in the fascia of the ramp leading up to the main entrance. This lead to our referring to an article by Irvine Green in 1979 on the eventual use of stone in buildings in the Doncaster/Templestowe area from 1843 with the construction of “Pontville” the home of Major Newman. Excerpts from Irvine’s article: 

The first homes built in this district were from mate- rials that were readily available. Bark, timber slabs and mud could be used to constrict shelter with the mini- mum of cost and time by settlers faced with the problem of establishing a farm on virgin ground. 

Major Newman lived in a mud house when he arrived at Templestowe, but as soon as he secured title to his land he built a stone house. Pontville was the first permanent house in the district. It was built in 1843. Ten years later he built a second stone house on the other side of Deep Creek called “Monkton”. 

Stone of varying quality is found all over the district and good quality stone has been quarried in several places. 


PORTERS HOUSE.  The stone house C.1860 stood in Whittens Road on the east side near the bend.


When many new expensive buildings were being planned for Melbourne, the Victorian Government offered a prize for a superior building stone. During the 1850’s and 1860’s several homes in our district were built of stone. Gottfried Thiele, the brother of Gottleib Thiele, a stonemason, built a stone section onto “Friedensruh” from their quarry on Ruffey’s Creek. David Corbett built a stone cottage on Doncaster Road opposite the golf links. At Templestowe August Fuhrmann and Henry White’s homes were built from local stone. 

In all these buildings, stone rubble was used in the walls with the corners built of squared stones. When Thomas Porter erected his home in Whittens Lane, the stone was layered in equally spaced courses with stones of equal length. When the house was demolished in the late 1920’s the stone was moved to Holy Trinity Doncaster to rebuild the old wooden chancel. However sandstone often deteriorates when exposed to the weather and only a few pieces were usable and used to build the memorial gates posts. 

Holy Trinity was built in 1868 with stone from Beanlands quarry in Church Road. The chancel used stone from Thiele’s quarry and when extensions were later made the council quarry was used. Schramm’s Cottage was also built from stone from the Beanlands quarry. 

Doncaster/Templestowe was fortunate to have had a rich collection of stone buildings, most of which have been lost to us.”

Source: Irvine Green excerpted in 2022-09 DTHS Newsletter

Deep Creek Primary and Doncaster East Primary School No 2096


Opened 1878
History ? Buildings altered ???
Significant Pupils ?Closed in 1997 when students moved to site of Waldau Primary School, Denhert St. The combined schools were renamed as Doncaster Gardens Primary School.

North west corner of George St and Blackburn Road.


The Headmaster's Horse

Mr Patrick W. Considine was the head teacher at Doncaster East Primary School from 1910 to 1914. For teachers today there are always complaints from parents about things affecting their chil- dren’s schooling and Mr Considine was not exempt from this with a complaint about his horse at school. 

An Overview of Change

 Our archivist and life long resident of Manningham, Ken Smith, has researched the many changes which have occurred in the municipality during his lifetime. Ken has compiled the following article which will enable long time residents to reminisce on the past and be interesting and informative for later residents in our community.

A large portion of the City of Manningham is shown on old government charts as “F. W. Unwin’s Special Survey”, comprising an area of 5120 acres (8 square miles), and taking in all of Doncaster, Lower Templestowe, Bulleen and part of Templestowe, west of Church Road and south of Foote Street, between the Yarra River and the Koonung Creek. 

This huge area was purchased in one block in March 1841 by a Sydney solicitor, Mr Frederic Wright Unwin, taking advantage of special regulations for the sale of crown land in the Port Phillip District of New South Wales (new Victoria). Mr Unwin paid 1 pound per acre, that is a total purchase price of 5,120 pounds. 

The land was then leased for grazing and agricul- tural purposes. It was known as the Carleton Estate. 

In the 1850’s, following the gold discoveries in Victoria, the estate was subdivided, and large parts of Doncaster and Lower Templestowe were sold to small farmers at prices averaging about 10 pounds an acre. 

After clearing their land and selling the wood, some settlers started to plants crops and small orchards and vineyards, and being situated at not too greater distance from the city of Melbourne were able to estab- lish a viable livelyhood. 

However, making a living from the land was hard work, especially for the first arrivals. The prosperous years leading up to the property boom of the late 1880’s saw some of the “gardeners” ie fruitgrowers selling their orchards to land speculators who intended to subdivide them into housing lots. It was believed then that a rail- way line would soon be built to Doncaster and urbani- sation would follow as in other areas like Box Hill, Surrey Hills and Heidelberg. 

In 1890 Doncaster broke away from the Shire of Bulleen and became a separate entity, and did not reu- nite with the Shire of Templestowe, the former Shire of Bulleen renamed, until 1915, by which time almost all of Doncaster, Lower Templestowe and Templestowe had developed to become Victoria’s largest fruitgrowing district. 

During the 1920’s another property boom resulted in several more orchards being subdivided for housing but, as was the case with the 1880’s boom, a financial depression prevented many houses being built. 

After the second world war, the arrival of large numbers of refugees from Europe and increased migra- tion from the UK, large scale home building and fac- tory construction commenced. Returned servicemen married, built homes – the “Baby Boom”. 

The Shire of Doncaster and Templestowe, being relatively close to the City was, like areas such as Waverley and East Bentleigh and East Burwood, poised for suburbanisation. Commencing about 1950, the orchards began to make way for housing estates. Macedon Square Shopping Centre was established in about 1957, with Village Avenue, off High Street Doncaster following soon after. A McPhersons Supa Valu Supermarket was built in Macedon Square in 1960. 

With increasing land values and a change in the Council rating system, the orchardists increasingly released they could no longer continue to grow fruit on the land their forefathers had pioneered one hundred years earlier. They sold out, retired or moved to areas further out such as Pakenham, Bacchus Marsh or the Mornington Peninsular. 

In 1965 land suitable for subdivision in Lowe Templestowe was worth 3,000 pounds per acre and the resulting ¼ acre lots were priced around 3,000 pounds per block. 

By the early 1970’s the transformation of Bulleen, Doncaster and Lower Templestowe was complete, with only residual pockets remaining in Templestowe, East Doncaster and Donvale. 

In the 1980’s another change occurred. Because of population pressure and urban sprawl, the Government started encouraging higher density living with smaller lot sizes and multiple buildings on suitable sites, especially in the vicinity of activity zones. Thus, houses on large blocks were purchased by developers as unit sites, a trend which has continued to the present time. With old houses on half-acre blocks now worth $3 Million, and quarter acres sites in strategic locations, for example near Westfield Doncaster Shoppingtown, worth even more. In 1978 a property in Tram Road, only 300 metres from Shoppingtown sold for $50,000. 

So, during the last 180 years, the forest of stringybark, yellow box and redgum has given way to graziers and timber cutters, then the fruitgrowers with their vast expanse of springtime blossom and bountiful harvests, which in turn made way for the triple fronted brick veneers of the 1950 – 70’s, and now the manifestation of modern living, the apartment building as typified by the transformation of the entire length of Doncaster Road. 

The largest industries now in the City of Manningham are construction and retail. Every post code now has its major shopping centre, catering for an ever increasing population, who, benefiting from increas- ing property values, can afford an affluent lifestyle with all the amenities of a first world country. 

Today, the City of Manningham is one of the most sought after places in Melbourne in which to live.

Source: Ken Smith writing in 2022-09 DTHS Newsletter

Gottlob “George” Schafter

Gottlob Schafter

Orchardist of Anderson’s Creek Road, Doncaster East

Like many people, as you get older you start to think more about your family background. When you are young, these thoughts are not at all in your mind and later in life, those family members who may have had some recollections or information have unfor- tunately passed away. 

So to satisfy my curiosity, I decided to find out as much as I could about my Gottlob Schafter. What did I really know other than that he was born in Germany and came to Melbourne sometime prior to 1900, became an orchardist in Doncaster East and raised a family. 

Rather than just finding out things like his birth, marriage and death details, I set out to find more details about his life including his earlier German roots, his sea voyage, his arrival in Australia and settling in Doncaster East, and his sub- sequent life as an orchardist and family man. 

It was quite surprising to find how much information was available but it required a bit of searching. Much of the information was found in old Victorian newspapers which are available on the internet under the National Library of Australia’s on-line “Trove” newspaper archive. Information was also found in the Public Records Office of Victoria’s archives, at the State Library of Victoria, at Births, Deaths and Marriages Victoria and other Government agencies and at the Doncaster Templestowe Historical Society. Some information was from other rela- tives of Gottlob, some of those who at the time I had not met. 

So what did I find out? 

Gottlob was born in the township of Brettach in Germany in 1864 and in 1889 migrated to Australia aboard the steamship Braunschweig arriving in Melbourne on 4th July after a 50 day sea voyage. It is unknown why Gottlob decided to come to Australia and Doncaster in Victoria in particular as many Germans had settled in South Australia as well as Victoria. Possibly Gottlob knew others from his Brettach hometown who had earlier come to Doncaster and established orchards. They may have written to one another about opportunities in Australia and in par- ticular Doncaster and given mail was carried by ship, it could have been up to 4-5 months between letters and a reply. The German port city of Bremerhaven near the city of Breman from were he left had become the major port of embarkation for German emigration and was the departure point for approximately 1.2 million emi- grants to the world by 1890. 

Gottlob and wife Lillian on their marriage day in 1893

Leaving Germany would have been a quite an emo- tional time for many emigrants as they were heading to a relative unknown life on the other side of the world and that they possibly would never see their families or relatives again. 

After his arrival in Melbourne, Gottlob appears to have travelled out to the then very much outer suburb of Doncaster East where many German families had estab- lished orchards. Shire of Doncaster rate records from 1892-93 onwards show that he leased and resided in a house on 40 acres of land on Andersons Creek Road just to the north-east of Reynolds Road where he initially became a farmer until progressively establishing an orchard on the land and in 1907 he finally purchased and obtained title to the land. 

In 1892 just 2½ years after his arrival, he married in the Salvation Army Melbourne headquarters a young girl named Lillian Gertrude Lapham who was aged just 18 years and they went on to have eight children - six boys and two girls. 

As well as maintaining his orchard, he was for a time on the committee of the Doncaster East Primary School where his children attended, was on the committee for the erection in 1906 of the St Phillips Anglican Church in Andersons Creek Road, and was the honorary auditor at the church for a number of years. 

By 1914 over 100,000 Germans lived in Australia and they were a well-established and liked community. When Britain declared war on Germany on 4th August 1914, it meant that Australia was also at war against Germany. For Germans in Australia, including those of German descent, life would never be quite the same again. Their former homeland was now the enemy and Australia had subsequently become a country of British and non-British persons and every person with a German heritage or name was under suspicion. Within a week of the declaration of war, German residents of Australia were forced to register with the police. 

The German families residing in Doncaster were therefore seen potentially by some as a threat. Gottlob was not above suspicion and a letter sent to the Australian Intelligence Corps at Victoria Barracks said
“I have been informed that there are spies (3) at August Zerbe’s orchard at Mitcham. They have a hidden wireless there, also probable rifles and ammunition. A fruit house would make a fine storeroom for large supplies of these things. If this is correct then Doncaster should be thoroughly and secretly searched especially the German shops, with probable secret cellars. An occasional search of the mailbags might also reveal how much money is being sent to Germany. I cannot give my informant’s name and address, but he says there are many disloyal residents there, who would harm us if possible. Last week also strange flashlights were seen by Box Hill residents after midnight. So search quickly I beg you before it’s too late.” 

A subsequent investigation by the Box Hill police reported 
“I have to report that I have made inquiries about Doncaster, and saw August Zerbe an orchardist residing at Warrandyte Road East Doncaster. He is an Australian native, and a thoroughly loyal British subject, as are all of the Zerbe’s in Doncaster (two families). I am satisfied the complaints refer to a German named Gottlob Schafter, a poor orchardist residing next door to the August Zerbe men- tioned. He is married with a large family, is 50 years of age and has been 20 years at East Doncaster”. 

The life of an orchardist was always busy. Land had to be ploughed, trees planted, watered, sprayed to keep insect pests and fungus controlled, fruit picked, packed, stored, taken to market, trees pruned, horses looked after, equipment maintained, maintenance of the family house and out-buildings, and the general providing for the family. There was little in the way of mechanical transport or equipment with the horse being the primary means for harnessing up and moving around equipment such as ploughs, harrows, hay mowers, cultivators, log rollers, spraying equipment, seed and fertiliser spreaders, carts etc and for transport of produce to market. Each orchardist would have had their own horse or horses for the work around the orchard and the use of the horse continued in many orchards well into the 1930s. 

While Gottlob was busy in the orchard, Lillian like most wives of the orchardists would be busy at home doing the cooking, washing, cleaning, milking cows, looking after the chooks, churning butter and tending to the vegetable garden. At the same time she would have been bringing up their young children. 

In 1917, his wife Lillian died aged just 42 years. The death of his wife was a difficult time for Gottlob as he had a baby daughter of just over 1 year of age and a number of other children that were still very young. As Gottlob still had the orchard to run and was struggling to also look after his children, orchardist friends August and Agnes Aumann and neighbours John and Bertha Pump offered to look after his two daughters and he made the difficult decision to “foster” out a daughter to each family for them to bring them up. They both remained with their foster families until they married at around 20 years of age. 

Following the lead of their father, sons Harry and Otto were later to own their own orchards nearby and son Ernest was also to become an orchardist taking part ownership of Gottlob’s orchard. 

Gottlob passed away in 1937 at the age of 73 years and was buried at Box Hill cemetery with his wife. Son Ernest subsequently took over full ownership of the orchard but early in 1939 tragically died at the age of 33 years while fighting bushfires in nearby Warrandyte that were part of the Black Friday fires sweeping Victoria. The land passed onto Ernest’s wife Dorothy who he had married just six weeks before his death but she died just three years later in 1942 at the age of 35 years without a will being in place. Ownership of the land subsequently transferred to Dorothy’s mother who sold the land in 1943 to the McKenzie family so ending the Schafter ownership and use of the land. 

But the name Schafter continued to be associated with orchards at Doncaster East. Sons Harry, Otto and later Harry’s son Albert retained orchards in the Doncaster area for many years until they later progres- sively sold off their land which was subdivided and devel- oped into residential housing estates. 

The City of Manningham is the local council for the Doncaster East area in which the Schafter family had its orchards. The council’s Landscape Management Plan writes: 

“A reserve and an orchard are both basically open land. The orchardist uses his land. He cultivates it, grows his crops, and harvests the fruit. The orchardist lives on his land and becomes part of it, and the land becomes part of him. When the orchardist leaves his land, the land is still identified with him. If the land becomes a reserve, the reserve becomes known by the name of the orchardist who is identi- fied with the land”. 

So when the orchard areas along Andersons Creek Road were redeveloped into residential land, one of the roads in the vicinity of Gottlob’s orchard was named “Schafter Drive”, and a parkland reserve off Schafter Drive was named “Schafter Reserve” in recog- nition of the Schafter name. 

From starting out not knowing much about my great grandfather, I have found much out about him, but I am still searching for more to include in his story. I intend to place a copy of my research in the Doncaster Templestowe Historical Society library when completed.”


Source: Ian Schafter writing in 2022-03 DTHS Newsletter


Pine Trees

 

The Pines

In 2019 it became necessary to remove many of the pine trees at our museum complex. The Manningham City Council arborist found many infected with a virus and in an unstable condition resulting in the removal of 53 trees. A replanting program is being planned by Council and DTHS. Eric Collyer’s article below tells the history of the trees.

The original trees in the Waldau cemetery were in all probability indigenous species such as eucalypts and acacia.  At a Christmas gathering of the Lutheran congregation soon after the church was opened in 1858 the church minister made reference to a “tea meeting” (gathering) held in the grounds in the shade of a few trees, after which those present went into the church as the bell rang for a Christmas service as darkness began to fall.
Early church ministers also recorded that in 1862 trees and shrubs from the Botanic Gardens (Melbourne) were planted in the cemetery.  Many of these were cypresses (commonly called “pencil pines” despite the fact that they are not pines but cypresses) which can be clearly seen in early photographs of the cemetery and most likely were a gift of Baron Ferdinand von Mueller who was director of the Gardens at the time.  A number of these trees still survive in the cemetery today.
The cemetery was in use from 1860 until 1888 when it was closed by Government decree for health reasons.  The original small church was in use until 1892 when it was replaced by the present church further south in Victoria Street then known as Bismarck Street.
Many years later, the cemetery was cared for by John Finger who lived close by, owned the surrounding land, was a greatly respected orchardist and a member of the congregation.  After he had retired from orchard work, he had time to maintain the cemetery in good order.
Around the end of the Second World War John was heartbroken one day to discover that some of the tombstones had been smashed by acts of vandalism.  Soon after, John was no longer able to care for the cemetery because of his age, and declining health.
At that time, John Simpfendorfer was pastor of the congregation.  His son Ken who worked in the State Forestry Department, sought permission from the congregation who still owned the site, to plant radiata pine with the intention of harvesting these trees for timber sale on maturity.  The plantation was established but the trees were never harvested as the Sirex Wood Wasp had made its way into the district and rendered the timber unsuitable for sale.
Orchardists in the area planted radiata pine as wind break rows to prevent high winds stripping fruit from trees or causing “limb rub” which marked the fruit.
The useful life of a pine tree is about 80 years and orchardists replanted windbreaks when trees began to deteriorate.
By 2019, many of the pines planted within the Schramm’s Cottage complex in the 1940s were either dead or dying or in a state of decline.  Some were unstable and a threat to public safety.  Manningham Council which now owns the site removed 53 of these trees.  Since then a further 4 pine trees have been removed.
Council plans to replace those removed with species similar in nature to those that were indigenous to the site such as eucalypts and acacia along with cypresses similar to those used in the original planting. 

Source: 2021-09 DTHS Newsletter


Representatives of Doncaster Templestowe Historical Society will work with Council officers to develop a planting scheme for the site.
John Finger is credited with introducing radiata pines into the district by bringing seed back from a trip to Europe (early 1900s) and raising seedlings to plant as windbreaks on his orchard.  In time many orchardists followed this practice.
In the 1940s the Collyer family rented a house that John Finger had built on his property just north of Schramm’s Cottage in Victoria Street, and ??? still remembers a row of old pine trees in front of this home being felled by contractors, dressed and loaded on trucks for milling.  He believes these were part of a regional planting.
Schramm’s School:
From 1860 until 1864 Max Schramm used the small wattle and daub church building on “Waldon Hill” as a school established by Trinity Lutheran congregation, presumably rearranging the furniture after Sunday service for the school week and back again for Sunday worship services.  This must have been inconvenient and also too small for a growing school enrolment so in 1865 after failing to secure a Government grant to build a larger school building on his land along Main Road (now Doncaster Road) at his own expense, he continued to operate the school there for the congregation.  He employed a “sewing mistress” to teach the infant grades and conducted the school until it was closed by the congregation in 1873 or thereabouts.  This later became a Common School and when the State Education Act came into being in 1874 Max resigned as teacher as he could not accept the requirement that education must be free, compulsory and SECULAR for all.  He sold his school building and built a cottage alongside in 1875?  The school was purchased by the Education Department and became a State School with AAOE Thiele as Head Teacher.  In later years the old building was adapted to become the E S & A Bank in Doncaster for many years.

Source:  Handwritten sheets dated 23 April, 2021.  Author unknown. 







Tullamore - Thomas Naghten Fitzgerald - Eastern Golf Club

Tullamore to Golf Course

With the pending sale of the Eastern Golf Course for commercial and residential development it is time to revisit the history of this site. In this district orchardists or farmers built their houses, the more successful they were the larger their home. One house "Tullamore" now the clubhouse of the Eastern Golf Club was an exception. It was built a~ the country home of Sir Thomas Fitzgerald, Melbourne's leading surgeon. The property of "Tullamore" had its origins in 1858 when the "Carlton Estate", north of Doncaster Road was subdivided. A grazing lease of over one square mile had previously extended across this area. The homestead and stockyard of this cattle station were located in the vicinity of the corner of Petty's Lane and Wilson's Road. The land, which later became the Eastern Golf Course, covered three blocks of approximately thirty acres each. One of these was bought by James Smith and the other two by David Mitchell. James Smith was the father of Laurie Smith, who became well known in the district as a drawing teacher. His brick home was built at the top of Elgar Road. David Mitchell bought his land as a farm; it became one of his four country properties. He built a small cottage on Doncaster Road opposite the stables. A Bunya Bunya pine that his daughter Dame Nellie Melba used to climb as a young girl marks the location of the cottage.


c1930Sir Thomas Fitzgerald's country home, "Tullamore" built in 1886 in Doncaster Road as a country home. It became Eastern Golf Club/ Links in 1924.  The oldest section of the building was built for Sir Thomas Fitzgerald, the eminent surgeon of the Melbourne Hospital. The property was later purchased by William Stutt, the owner of the Doncaster Hotel. This photograph is a copy of one that appeared in a newspaper or magazine, and shows the new additions on the east side.  Dr Fitzgerald named the property 'Tullamore', by which name it was known for many years after Fitzgerald ceased to be the owner. DP0216 

Josiah Mackenzie – Scapegoat or Scoundrel

This very interesting article on Joshua Mackenzie has been researched and compiled by Kay Mack, our archivist for many years. We are grateful to Kay for the many hours of patient research she has devoted to the article and we are sure members shall find the story interesting and fascinating.

Josiah Mackenzie was the Doncaster Shire engineer question: Scapegoat or Scoundrel? 



Tennis in Doncaster Templestowe

Tennis in Templestowe in the Early Days


Society member Diana Mayne has generously compiled this article giving us a wealth of information
on the early days of tennis in the Templestowe area. This information will be of great interest to
members particularly those who were born and have lived in Templestowe and surrounds.

In 1912 the first two public tennis courts were built on the east side of Ruffey Creek adjacent to Parker Street, on land now occupied by Templestowe Bowling Club. They were constructed by the local com- munity, mainly orchardists and dairy farmers, using farm equipment – Clydesdale horses pulling ploughs, scoops and graders. Initially the ground was cleared of vegetation, ploughed, then levelled using scoops and a horse drawn blade, and finally rolled to produce a hard dirt and gravel surface to play on. In 1914, a third court was constructed in like manner in the newly proclaimed (1910) Templestowe Recreation Reserve in Porter St, on the eastern side of the cricket ground. The Parker St courts were asphalted by the Shire Council in the early 1920s, and the third court, which was usually referred to by players as the ‘Top Court’, probably later. It cer- tainly had an asphalt surface by the 1930s. 

1920's on the "Top Court". Ethel Aumann, sister of Fred and Bertha from the Carl Aumann orchard in Serpells Rd.

A moderately substantial pavilion was built on the east side of the Parker St courts by carpenter Ted Sheahan (from the Templestowe Hotel family) on his return from WW1. He was the Secretary of Templestowe Tennis Club. At some stage, a shed (not grand enough to be called a pavilion) was erected beside the Top Court to serve the needs of the players there (store the net, have afternoon tea, sit in the shade while watching play). The front of it features in early 1920s photographs, with ladies playing on the dirt surface in long dresses or skirts and men in trousers. Not everyone wore white. The Templestowe Reserve court was officially opened on 30th October 1914 by the wife of the Federal Member for Kooyong, this electorate taking in a large swathe of eastern Melbourne at the time. It was recorded thus in the “Box Hill Reporter” in its 6th November edition. 

Templestowe Tennis Club


“The Templestowe park tennis club held a ‘basket pic- nic’ in the recreation reserve on Friday afternoon October 30, the occasion being the official opening of the new court, which ceremony was ‘performed’ by Lady Best. Residents of the district attended in large numbers, and a thoroughly enjoyable afternoon was passed. The club president (Mr. W. J. Ross) introduced Lady Best, who unfurled a large Union Jack presented to the club by Mr. Ross, and as the colours were hoisted to the head of the flagstaff, the gather- ing joined in the National Anthem. In welcoming the guests present and referring to the events which led up to the possession of a tennis court by the residents of Templestowe, the president contended that not only those residing in Lower Templestowe, but the whole of the district should recognise that they had an interest in the park and should try to improve it. Lady Best in declaring the court open for play, apologised for the absence of Sir Robert Best, and congratulated the club on being in possession of such a valu- able adjunct, hoping that the court would conduce to the enjoyment of the residents. She then untied the blue and white ribbon, being the club colours, suspended across the court, which was received with three hearty cheers. The popular secretary of the club, Mr. E. P. Sheahan, on its behalf, thanked Lady Best for her attendance. Several games were played during the afternoon, and the court promises to become a centre of healthy enjoyment for the members.” 



Templestowe tennis pavilion group c1920. The tennis courts were on the position of the present bowling green. c1920. DP0529  Tennis pavilion and players, on the site of the present bowling green, Swilk Street, Templestowe. Mr Searby, the Head Master of Templestowe Primary School (1914-1928), is the elderly gentleman at the back, and Miss Dora Bogle is the young lady at the left hand end of the front row with the hat. Olive Williamson and Isabel Margaret ['Girlie'] Williamson are also in the front row, being respectively 2nd and 3rd from the left hand end of the row. Dora Bogle's sister Gladys is also in the front row being fourth from the left hand end. Ted Sheahan, who was a carpenter, built the tennis pavilion as his first job after his return from military duties during WW1. Ted Sheahan is in this photo and is in the back row, third from the left, between the two ladies wearing hats. It is believed the photo was taken on the opening of the pavilion in 1920.  Pauline Hartman identified Gladys Bogle, following publication of this photo in the Sunday Herald Sun on 15 April 2012. Gladys Bogle married Tobe Pump. The Templestowe Park Tennis Club celebrated its centenary with a function on Sunday 29 April 2012, when its commemorative book entitled 'A Century of Tennis in Tempy' was launched by the mayor of the City of Manningham, Cr Geoff Gough.  

The photograph was taken at the opening of the pavilion in 1920 and third from the left in the back row is Ted Sheahan, the builder of the pavilion. The older man with the hat at the back is Robert Searby who was headmaster of the Templestowe Primary School and retired in 1928. The only other people definitively identified are the three ladies on the left in the front row. From left to right, they are Miss Dora Bogle from a Doncaster orchard on the south side of Manningham Road, Miss Olive Williamson (born 1899), from an orchard on the southwest corner of Manningham Road and Ayr Street, and her cousin Isobel (called 'Girlie') Williamson (born 1900) from a High Street orchard. (Notes from Century of Tennis in Tempy)



Ted Sheahan’s pavilion at the Parker St courts was officially opened in 1920. There is no surviving report of this occasion, but an excellent photograph exists show- ing 25 people at the front of the pavilion, about half in tennis clothes, with Mr Robert Searby, the headmaster of Templestowe Primary School, at the centre of the back row. It may well have been him who officiated. 

These three courts, and a few private courts, served the tennis playing community until 1960-early 1961, when they were replaced by two en-tout-cas courts in the northwest corner of Templestowe Reserve, and Templestowe Tennis Club relocated there. Fences were removed, and Templestowe Bowling Club (which had started in 1948) extended over the Parker St courts with an enlarged bowling green and car park. The pavilion, however, was left standing until Ted Sheahan died in 1967. The Top Court was converted to two cricket nets, and the shed demolished. 

A note on Templestowe Reserve is appropriate here – to acknowledge the hard work and foresight of council- lors of the late 1950s and early 1960s, particularly Councillor Swilk (who has had a very short street named after him!). By December 1959, the Council had acquired the Hawtin dairy farm after protracted negotiations, and the Reserve was enlarged from just over 4 acres to 12 acres. This made room for much improved community facilities for the rapidly growing population, including scouts and guides, remote control motor sports, eventu- ally 7 tennis courts, an enlarged main oval, a second oval, and a football / cricket pavilion (which was replaced in 2009). The first tennis clubhouse was completed in 1964 and later enlarged twice (all financed by the mem- bers), and in 2018 it was renovated at Council expense. 

Names of families using the three original courts will be familiar to many whose roots are in this area. During the 1920s and 1930s, families from the western part of Templestowe and Lower Templestowe were the main players at the Parker St courts. They included: WILLIAMSON, HODGSON, CLAY, BOGLE, SHEAHAN, SMITH (High St orchard), CASHEN, LANCASTER, MAHONEY and Marie FINN (from Finn’s Hotel). The main families using the Top Court were predominantly from the eastern side of Templestowe, and include: PETTY, AUMANN, BEALE, CHIVERS, UEBERGANG, CLAY, RASMUSSEN, CROUCH, JENKINS, CARRICK, FITZSIMONS, MUNDY, READ, ROTH, SERPELL and SMITH (from dairy farms east of where Williamsons Road now runs). The most talented player, by repute, was Percy Rasmussen, who could have ‘gone far’! 

After WW2, the Top Court no longer entered Saturday afternoon teams for competition, so the keen competitors transferred to the Parker St courts. The Top Court, however, continued to be a valuable community asset, especially for young people playing social tennis and ‘having a good time’. (Some of the stories from these days are fascinating!) 

With the subdivision of farms and orchards and sub- sequent transformation of Templestowe into a residential suburb of Melbourne in the 1960s, tennis took a new turn. Along with the growth of the tennis club and two more courts added, the acre block developments from the 1960s to the 1980s saw over 100 private tennis courts being built, just in the suburb of Templestowe, probably a world record for one suburb! Some were never used, but most were, and many of the families owning these courts joined clubs including Templestowe Park Tennis Club (the new name since the 1970s). When Templestowe had too many teams for its own courts, the overflow could always be relocated to play on the private courts of club members. 

Back to the “Old Days”, many of the families playing tennis were also prominent in the Templestowe Cricket Club and Templestowe Football Club. For example, Albert (‘Alby’) Petty, an orchardist from the east end of Porter Street (a cousin of the Monckton Road Pettys), was a remarkable sportsman. He featured in Templestowe Football Club’s 1929 Premiership team photograph as a youth. He was a good cricketer and became President of Templestowe Cricket Club during the 1950s. A good ten- nis player, he was President of Templestowe Tennis Club from 1952 to 1965 and was made a Life Member in 1967. He also played bowls and golf. He was a major contribu- tor to the community in other ways as well – Secretary of the Memorial Hall Committee, one of the organisers of the Cup Day gymkhanas held at Templestowe Reserve until the mid 1960s (the manure left behind was not appreciated by cricketers the following Saturday!), and was involved in fundraising for the Box Hill Hospital Auxiliary from which he also received Life Membership. 

Early Templestowe was indeed a remarkable community.

Source: Diana Mayne writing in 2020-03 DTHS Newsletter





Members of the Doncaster Tennis Club. The Doncaster Tennis Court was at the rear of the Doncaster Primary School, and the north-east corner of Federal Park. Unfortunately, none of this large group of people is identified.  | Other Information: Joan Seppings Webster mentions Federal Park, Council Street Doncaster, in an article in the Doncaster Mirror, 30 July 1986.  DP0312


Rotary Club of Doncaster

The Rotary Club of Doncaster and its Association with The Doncaster Templestowe Historical Society and the Community


The Rotary Club of Doncaster was chartered in August 1972 and in 2022 will celebrate their 50th anniversary. 

The charter President was Doug White, Vice President Ken Clark, Secretary Dave Donaldson, Treasurer Ron Douglas and Board Members David East, Bill Ulrich, Fred Andrew, John Hirst, David Perry, Milton Warn. The club was chartered with 35 members. 

From the beginning Rotary had a strong association with the Doncaster Templestowe Historical Society mainly through the Society member Irvine Green who was granted honorary membership of Rotary in 1976. Irvine was also an historian and that is how The Rotary Club became involved with the Society. Irvine was Chairman of the Schramm’s Cottage Preservation Committee when the cottage was moved from Doncaster Road to its present position in 1974. 

In 1976 Rotary’s Community Service Committee built a shed in the grounds of Schramm’s Cottage for the display of the Society’s collection of orchard and farming equipment; I suspect with Society member Irvine Green being instrumental in suggesting this. The rebuilding of the cottage and restoration work on early orchard machinery were opportunities for Rotary to strengthen the ties between the two organisations. Rotary’s involvement also included working with ociety members in rebuilding the Gazebo from the Templestowe Cemetery in the cottage grounds. This association continues today with Rotary members assisting with the maintenance of the cottage gardens and general maintenance. 

In 2000 the Historical Society allowed Rotary to erect a shed, known as “Lindsay’s Shed” for storing Rotary equipment and records. That year Rotary mem- ber Basil Ornellas recorded the commentary for each of the display rooms in Schramm’s Cottage, Atkins Cottage, the Sloyd Room and Fingers Barn. 

Schramm’s Cottage Museum Complex is only one of the Community Service projects that Rotary is involved in. Some others are: Doncare – assistance with funding and Christmas hampers – Twilight Disco – for the benefit of less abled people; Dabs – basketball for less abled students; RSL – assistance with funding and hampers; a pathway and recreational area for Manningham Centre; Various forums addressing Hearing Impairment, Vision and Mental Health Awareness.

Source: Liz Olie writing in 2021-12 DTHS Newsletter


Rotary Club of Doncaster has contributed to many community projects in a wide range of areas over many years.


They provided plaques in the grounds of Schramm Cottage Museum Complex. See: https://portal.clubrunner.ca/4002/PhotoAlbums/schramm-s-cottage-1


Rotary have also worked on preservation of the Waldau cemetery within the Schramm Cottage Museum Complex:






See also:
https://portal.clubrunner.ca/4002/
https://www.facebook.com/rotarydoncaster2
https://portal.clubrunner.ca/4002/PhotoAlbums/schramm-s-cottage-1


Rotary Organisation


Guest Speaker at our November meeting was Pat Armstrong a member of the Rotary Club of Doncaster. Pat gave a most enlightening and informative power point presentation on the scope of work undertaken by Rotary International and its affiliated clubs throughout the world. 
Some interesting facts gleaned from Pat’s talk: 
  • Rotary International was established in 1912 
  • Current membership is 1.2 million 
  • There are 39,000 clubs working in 200 countries throughout the world 
  • Africa, Asia and India are countries of significant growth in terms of service. 
Pat also highlighted some major environmental problems in various parts of the world today and how Rotary International is involved in helping to overcome these. For example Rotarians Against Malaria (RAM) provides mosquito nets in countries where malaria is a major concern. Funds have also been provided to ultimately eradicate the incidence of polio throughout the world. Over the past 30 years this has been reduced by 99% through the immunisation of 2.5 billion children. Rotary International has contributed UA$1.8 billion to this program. Rotary International is also closely associated with the Bulawayo Orphans Education Project by funding school fees and teacher training programs and providing books and food supplements for children. On the local horizon, Rotary clubs are also involved in sustainability programs such as the planting and growing of trees raised from seeds. Rotary Doncaster is also currently involved in a project to help eliminate weed infestation at Anderson Creek (Warrandyte) by planting other grasses to suppress it. 

Our sincere thanks to Pat for a most interesting presentation as evidenced by the number of questions from our members and for the ongoing support of members of Doncaster Rotary at our monthly working bees at Schramm’s Cottage. 

Source: Eric Collyer writing in 2019-12 DTHS Newsletter



-


-

Zelius Family

Wedding Bells.

On the 7th inst., an interesting and unique wedding took place at the Church of Christ, Doncaster, when Mr W. J. Lacey was united to Miss Edith Zelius. Mr Lacey is a nephew of Mr and Mrs James Gill, of Box Hill, being related on both sides. His father was an old resident of Templestowe, and was well-known in the district. He moved years ago, however, to West Australia, so that the bridegroom considers himself a Westralian. The Zelius family are old and highly-respected residents of Doncaster. The chapel was beautifully decorated for the occasion, and a triumphal arch was erected over the gateway. The ceremony, which was an impressive one, was performed by Mr F. W. Greenwood, evangelist of the church. Mr Cassidy presided at the organ, rendering the "Wedding March" in an efficient manner. Mr Bert. Gill, cousin of the bridegroom, acted as groomsman, while Misses Alice and Ruby Zelius, sisters of the bride, and Misses Laura and Ruby Embley, daughters of Dr Embley, of Melbourne, acted as bridesmaids. The bride looked at her best in a dress of rich white silk, trimmed with a pretty contrast of lace. The bridesmaids also wore white silk, and carried white and pink bouquets, and were adorned with gold brooches richly set with pearls, the gift of the bridegroom. The bride's present was a handsome gold watch and chain. At the conclusion of the ceremony the happy couple drove off to the home of the bride's parents, in a carriage and pair. All day long the cabs of Box Hill, which were hired for the day, were busy driving over the guests as they arrived by train from town and other places. The guests, 80 in number, sat down to a bounteous wedding breakfast, which was provided at the residence of the bride's parents. The usual toasts were proposed and duly honored, but only "soft" drinks were used, as all concerned were total abstainers, as in fact were the whole of the guests. The bride has been a member of the Church of Christ at Doncaster for some years, and the groom is a member of the same church in W.A. The happy couple left the same night for Queenscliff for a short honeymoon, and sailed on the 14th for their home in W.A. During the two or three months that Mr Lacey has been in Box Hill he has won the favor of the tradespeople and others by his open-handed dealings, and as he has good business prospects in the West, it is hoped that with his religious and benevolent principles he will do good work for his fellow men. He will be ably seconded by his wife in every good work. This paper wishes them a long and useful life.

1903 'Wedding Bells.', Reporter (Box Hill, Vic. : 1889 - 1918), 16 January, p. 2. , viewed 22 Feb 2018, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article90320213


A forgotten pioneer of Doncaster

Need image

On a warm summer day visitors to the Schramm’s Cottage Historic Complex enjoy sitting on the garden seat in the shade of the Elm tree admiring the colourful plants growing in the garden. This seat was given to the Society new in 2010 by the great granddaughter of Martin Zelius and was manufactured by the Furphy Foundry in Shepparton who also made the famous water carts many years ago. A plague on the seat reads “In Memory of the Zelius Family, Early Pioneers of Doncaster.” 

Visitors often ask about the Zelius family as the name is not widely known. No road, park or buildings are named after the Zelius family in Manningham unlike the many other pioneer family names that have been remembered in this way. An article by the late Irvine Green was published in the Society’s Newsletter in 1972 about “Plassy” the house built by Martin Zelius in 1888 and a similar article was included in the book “Doncaster a Short History” published by our Society in 1994. Extensive research has been recently undertaken by several of our members with the results now filed away in our amazing archive collection. 

Martin Zelius was born in the year 1837. At the age of 14 years in Norway he joined a merchant sailing ship as a seaman and his first voyage was to Australia. On arrival in Melbourne the ship’s crew deserted to join the gold rush leaving Martin Zelius stranded with no money and little knowledge of the English language. He was resourceful and got a job as a kitchen hand washing dishes in a restaurant in William Street, Melbourne. Years later he became the owner of the business and in 1869 held the 15 year lease on the property at 175 pounds per annum. The business was known as the Western Dining Rooms and Boarding House at 4 & 5 William Street. 

He had built up the business and during the Royal visit to Melbourne by the Duke of Edinburgh in 1867 Martin invited the poor and homeless people of Melbourne for a free meal in his restaurant. 

Martin became an active member of the Church of Christ in Melbourne and was married in 1861 to Euphemia McEwan but unfortunately Euphemia died in February 1867 aged 34 years. There were no children from this marriage. Later in 1867 Martin married Eliza Furness and they had 4 sons and 8 daughters. 

Martin bought the famous coastal steam ship “Lady of the Lake” and traded along the Gippsland coast and Melbourne. He sold his restaurant business, built a house in Bairnsdale and moved there with his family in the late 1870’s. In 1888 he sold the family home and the ship “Lady of the Lake” before trade slackened off as a result of the railway coming. He then bought land in Doncaster and built brick stables with a high pitched roof where the family lived whilst their house was constructed. The house was named “Plassy” and quickly became known as the most elegant house in Doncaster with its wide verandah trimmed with iron lace. Martin established an orchard adjoining “Plassy” achieving another successful business. 

Martin and his family became members of the Church of Christ in Doncaster and he was a Deacon of the Church during its 40th Anniversary in 1903. Several of their daughters were married at the church. Martin died at his home “Plassy” Main Road, Doncaster on 27th December 1908, the following day a horse drawn hearse and funeral procession left his home for interment in Melbourne General Cemetery. 

Eliza Zelius continued to live at Plassy until her death in 1932. The 4 sons of Martin and Eliza Zelius all operated orchards of 36 acres in Doncaster Road, 21 acres and 10 acres in Leeds Street, 37 acres in Blackburn Road and in Woodhouse Grove, Box Hill. Two daughters went to New Zealand and married there. Others married and moved away from Doncaster. The family became scattered and their properties sold during the 1960’s for residential development. The family home remained although the stables were demolished in the early 1960’s and the house “Plassy” sold. 

The house is still a private home today hidden behind a high brick wall only identified as 891 Doncaster Road. It is the only 19th century house on Doncaster Road and was built by a “Forgotten Pioneer of Doncaster”. 

Source: John Boylett writing in 2019-12 DTHS Newsletter





History of Radio

A passionate radio enthusiast, Phil Palmer, spoke at our June meeting on “The History of Radio”. His enthusiasm drew members to a very informative address and reminded us of some of the important timelines in this history. His detailed story highlighted some of those timelines including: 
  •  In 1901 the constitution gave the Federal Government power over postal telegraph, telephone and other services.
  • The 1905 Wireless Telegraphy Act saw Marconi building the first two-way radio from Queensland to Victoria.
  • In 1906 official transmission from Queenscliff in Victoria to Devonport, Tasmania took place.
  • 1921 saw the first radio licence issued and in 1924 Radio 3AR-LO was established, followed by 2UE in 1925.
  • In 1927 AWA commenced transmission to England with the original broadcast heralded by the famous Kookaburra Laugh. Station 3DB also started that year. 
 Technology advanced dramatically, ham radio enthusiasts were many and in the 1940’s Crawford Productions commenced. The depression years and WW2 played an integral part in the progress of radio. Phil’s old radio demonstrations were amazing, the sound quality was incredible from his well-loved and cared for treasurers. Thank you Phil for your detailed and interesting presentation. 

Source: Glenys McIntyre writing in the 2019-09 DTHS Newsletter

Ben Nevis and the Duncan Family

The Duncan Family

Charles Smith and his sister Margaret Williamson, descendants of Isabella Smith of Ben Nevis Bulleen, have donated three oil paintings to Schramm's Cottage. They show the parents of Isabella Smith, Mrs Isabella Duncan, her husband, Alexander Duncan and her grandfather Mr. Roland Ramsay.

These large portraits were painted in Scotland and brought out by the Duncans when they came to Bulleen in 1839. They hung in their small wattle and daube hut on the banks of Koonung Creek.

Mrs Isabella Duncan wife of Alexander Duncan, in the front garden of her wattle and daub house near the intersection of Bulleen Road and Thompsons Road at Bulleen. Alexander and Isabella settled in Bulleen in or about the year 1847 and leased one of the farms on the Carlton Estate. DP0664, DP0395) 

Later they hung on the walls of the two story mansion Ben Nevis. When the family sold Ben Nevis they went to Isabella's granddaughter, Mrs. Sinclair of North Balwyn, until her death in 1985.

Front of 'Ben Nevis', corner of Thompsons and Bulleen Roads, Bulleen, showing the extensive use of lacework around the verandahs and polychrome brickwork. There are three men, two women and two dogs on the lawn. The elderly gentleman is probably George Smith who had the house built about 1890. The elderly lady seated next to him is probably his wife, formerly Miss Duncan, a daughter of Alexander Duncan, one of the earliest settlers in the area. The house is now in Ben Nevis Court, Bulleen. DP0394

Alexander Duncan ran a dairy farm on the banks of the Yarra. The first church service in the district was held in their barn in 1843. A cheese churn was used as an altar and the congregation sat on planks laid across barley sacks. Alexander's daughter Isabella married their neighbour George Smith.  Later, George purchased the Duncan land and in 1890 built the two story mansion Ben Nevis, still standing on the hill above the Sentimental Bloke Hotel

Duncan's cheese factory 1903  Photograph of a painting of Alexander Duncan's cheese factory which is stated to have been in Thompsons road near the present group of shops. DP0400

Source: 1990-09 DTHS Newsletter







Label: Isabella DUNCAN. Wife of Alexander Duncan. Portrait painted in Scotland before she left for Australia in 1839. There is a photograph of Isabella in front of a wattle and daub hut at Bulleen, in the Pioneer Women dispiay in the schooiroom.




The Duncan Family of Bulleen.


In the Doncaster-Templestowe Historical Society’s museum collection, the oldest items are three large framed portraits painted in 1835. These are of Roland Ramsay, a wealthy land owner and farmer of Melrose, Roxburghshire, Scotland, his 21 year old daughter Isabella and Alexander Duncan, a groom from the family stables. Isabella and Alexander were married in 1835 although Roland Ramsay at first did not like the idea of his daughter marrying one of his servants.


These three life size portrait, by an unidentified artist, were given to Isabella by her father as a parting gift as she with Alexander and their two daughters left Scotland, for Australia in 1839 on the vessel “Midlothian”.  They arrived in Melbourne during June 1839 and then soon established a home in a wattle and daub hut built by Alexander alongside the Koonung Creek in Bulleen where it enters the Yarra River.  The home included Isabella's piano, a few pieces of furniture fro Scotland and these three portrait paintings.

Isabella’s and Alexander’s eldest son James was born in Bulleen during 1841 and the family continued to increase increase to include 4 sons and 5 daughters.

Alexander worked hard and drained the swamps, cleared and ploughed the land, planted wheat and Bali, which was harvested and exported to England, were it was classified as high-quality.  Frequent flooding by the river and Creek made growing crops difficult, which led to changing to dairy cattle farming.

The first church service in the the Manningham district was held by the Presbyterians in December 1843, in the Duncans barn on Bulleen Road. The pews were boards supported by bags of grain, a cheese churn covered by a tablecloth was used as the altar, and the baptismal font was a China basin.  Monthly services were held in the barn conducted by the Rev. Forbes who was the first Presbyterian minister resident in Melbourne.

Alexander died in 1857 leaving their eldest son James now 16 years old to run the established family dairy farm of 94 acres. He built a new barn and cheese factory in Thompsons Road where the shops are today. 

Their eldest daughter born in Scotland and also named Isabella married a Scottish neighbour called George Smith. They eventually purchased the Duncan’s family farm and in 1890 built a two story mansion in Bulleen called “Ben Nevis”, still standing as a prominent home today.

On the 13th October 1902 Isabella Duncan (nee Ramsay) died at the age of 88 years. Of Isabella’s large family only two daughters and two sons survived her with many grandchildren and five great grandchildren.
 
These three portrait paintings were moved from the small wattle and daub hut to hang on the Ben Nevis mansion. When the family sold Ben Nevis the paintings went to Isabella’s granddaughter, Mrs Sinclair (nee Smith) of North Balwyn until her death in 1985. Charles Smith and his sister Margaret Williamson, great grandchildren of Isabella and Alexander Duncan, then donated these three treasured portrait paintings to Doncaster-Templestowe Historical Society.


Label: Roland RAMSAY:  Faiher of Isabella Duncan. Portrait painted in Scotland and brougit out by the Duncans.

Source: John Boylett writing in 2019-09 DTHS Newsletter








Ben Nevis - 21-25 Ben Nevis Grove, Bulleen

George Smith, a noted early settler of the Bulleen area, built Ben Nevis in 1890.
He purchased the land from three gentlemen: William Clarke,
Joseph Clarke and Patric McCaughan, directors of the Chatsworth Estate Company. Before George Smith actually settled in the area, it was leased to David Murray by Robert  Campbell.
It is believed that George Smith first settled in the vicinity of the present Camberwell Municipal Golf Course.

Ben Nevis from Bulleen Road in 1940: Where the cows are grazing is now the car park for the Sentimental Bloke Hotel.  Behind the large tree in the centre is a chicory kiln.  Chicory was grown on the river flats.


George Smith came out from Inverness, Scotland, in 1853/54 at the age of 24.  He purchased land alongside the Duncan family and later married one of the Duncan girls. He became a dairy farmer and was quite successful.  In 1881, George took first prize with his cheese at the Melbourne Exhibition.
In 1857, his parents, John and Elizabeth and his brothers Tom, David, John. James and Joseph came to Templestowe.  All of them are buried in the Templestowe Cemetery under the Presbyterian denomination.
The Smith family had a major role in the development of both the Templestowe and Bulleen area.  Apart from being a well-known dairy farmer, his brother Joseph was a councillor for Templestowe from 1883 to 1895.  Others were involved with the Cemetery trust.  David was
 a trustee from 1877 to 1893.  Tom was a trustee from 1894 to 1912. There is an avenue within the cemetery dedicated to the Smith family in appreciation and commemoration of their involvement.
The house was built in 1890. It is named ·after the mountain "Ben Nevis" in Scotland for it is built on the highest point of the land, to avoid the flooding that often occurred on the river flats.
Mr and Mrs T S White were the second owners of Ben Nevis.  They purchased it in 1939 and sold it last year.  During their forty year ownership of the grand old house many alterations carried out.
The house was built of brick with an interplay of distinctive tones, but is now completely painted white.
  The verandah which used to extend around the front and side originally consisted of wooden flooring, ornate cast iron work, and an iron roof.  The timber floor had rotted and the railings were loose so the verandahs have been removed leaving a concrete paved terrace.
Many alterations can be seen in the interior of the house.  The rear has been adapted to suit a modern style of living.  A large mess room, once used by the workers on the farm, was divided to give a rear staircase, sunroom and laundry. A more convenient kitchen and comfortable dining room was built.
Originally the only bedroom downstairs was a servant’s room. All the family bedrooms were upstairs.  When 
Mr. and Mrs. White purchased the house they transformed the extra sitting areas downstairs into extra bedrooms.
Two major alterations were required within the 'house. There was no electricity and the windows were very small.  When electricity was acquired, simple light fittings were hung from the ornate rose ceilings. With the small windows, the house seemed very dark and gloomy. This was quite common with houses built at that time.  The Whites put in 
new windows.  Most were floor length settings.
Other minor alterations included the marble fireplaces.  Only one of the original is left.  The others have been closed off for practical reasons and one has been remodeled.
Another major alteration over the years was the land size. The land has been dramatically divided.
This was only to be expected due to the development of Bulleen as a suburb.  The original land extended for some 200 acres whereas now the land size is around one acre.
Present day occupants of the original lease include Marcellin College, Carey Grammar, a municipal golf course, recreation parks and the Sentimental Bloke Hotel.
Another point of interest was that the driveway from the house used to extend right down to Thompsons Road through an avenue of gum trees.  When the land was subdivided in 1965, it had to be shortened to Ben Nevis Grove.
The house itself was a mostly furnished in antiques purchased by and also given to Mr. and Mrs. White over the years. They greatly enhanced the grandeur of the house.
The building is under its third
 owner and without doubt there will
 be more changes in the years to come.  Ben Nevis has been a prominent landmark in the area and has contributed to the history and development of Bulleen.

Source: Mary Kuliveovski writing in 1980-02 DTHS Newsletter reprinted in 2015-12 DTHS Newsletter


Ben Nevis - 21-25 Ben Nevis Grove, Bulleen

Of local historical significance for its associations with George Smith and his early farming enterprise in the district.




Source: Victorian Heritage Database: http://vhd.heritagecouncil.vic.gov.au/places/22354


Ben Nevis - 21-25 Ben Nevis Grove, Bulleen - Google Street View

GoogleStreetView Feb2014



Ben Nevis - 21-25 Ben Nevis Grove, Bulleen

Ben Nevis' is a large, detached, double-storey house with rendered walls and a slate roof. The verandah (front elevation) is enclosed within projecting walls and has cast iron lacework decoration on both levels. An old photograph of the building [1] shows that formerly the verandah extended at least around the left hand side of the building, if not around the entire house. The underlying brickwork is polychromatic. There are two symmetrically placed bay windows on the ground floor of the front elevation. There is a porch on the left hand side of the building which is a later addition.
There have been some external renovations including some new windows, a new cast-iron fence, which retails the old gate and pillars and the rendering itself.

'Ben Nevis', a large, detached, double-storey house with rendered walls and a slate roof, was built c.1890 for George Smith 1890 [2]. George Smith was the first of his family to emigrate from Scotland in 1853/4. He was joined by his parents and five brothers in 1857 and the family became major dairy farmers in the region. Originally the farmland extending around the house covered approximately 200 acres (now it is about one acre).
In 1939 the property was sold by the Smith family to the Whites, in whose ownership it was to remain for the next forty years and who carried out most of the present alterations.

SOURCES
[1] Hazel Poulter, 'Templestowe a Folk History', 1985, p.27.
[2] Doncaster Templestowe Historical Society Newsletter February 1980.


Condition: Excellent 
Integrity: Intact 
Associations: George Smith. Of local historical significance for its associations with George Smith and his early farming enterprise in the district.

c.1890 
Local Themes: 5.01 - Squatters, selectors & small farmer

Source: Manningham Heritage Study Context Pty. Ltd. Page 5-6


Ben Nevis and the Smith Family

The land which is now Westerfolds Park was originally part of the Unwin Special Survey, and later (1863-1936) a large dairy farm be- longing to the Smith family, called "Holyrood Park". Other places associated with this large farming family include "Ben Nevis". In 1973 the parkland was purchased by the State Government for use as public open space(1).

Reference: 1. Doncaster Templestowe Historical Society Newsletter, March 1985.

Source: From City of Doncaster and Templestowe Heritage Study 1991 Richard Peterson OCR.pdf
http://www.manningham.vic.gov.au/file/26126/download

"Ben Nevis" . 21-25 Ben Nevis Grove Bulleen (129.09)

"Ben Nevis", a large, detached, double-storey house with rendered walls and a slate roof, was built for George Smith in 1890 (1). The verandah (front elevation) is enclosed within projecting walls and has cast iron lacework decoration on both levels. An old photograph of the building2 shows that formerly the verandah extended at least around the left hand side of the building, if not around the entire house. The underlying brickwork is polychromatic. There are two symmetrically placed bay windows on the ground floor of the front elevation. There is a porch on the left hand side of the building which is a later addition. There have been some external renovations including some new windows, a new cast-iron fence, which retains the old gate and pillars and the rendering itself.

George Smith was the first of his family to emigrate from Scotland in 1853/4. He was joined by his parents and fIve brothers in 1857 and the family became major dairy farmers in the region. Originally the farmland extending around the house covered approximately 200 acres (now it is about one acre).

In 1939 the property was sold by the Smith family to the Whites, in whose ownership it was to remain for the next forty years and who carried out most of the present alterations.

Of local historical significance for its associations with George Smith and his early farming enterprise in the district.

1. Doncaster Templestowe Historical Society Newsletter February 1980.
2. Hazel Poulter - Templestowe & Folk History 1985. p. 27.

Source: From City of Doncaster and Templestowe Heritage Study 1991 Richard Peterson OCR.pdf
http://www.manningham.vic.gov.au/file/26126/download

Ben Nevis 21-25 Ben Nevis Grove, Bulleen. 

This property has a long association with major district dairy farmers.  George Smith Sen., the first owner of Ben Nevis, occupied a farm on 60 acres on Bulleen Road in the late 1880s. This farm was owned by Robert Campbell and Co.(28), who were responsible for the 1850s Carlton Estate farm subdivision of Unwins Special Survey. This covered most of the present day Bulleen(29).  A house occupied by Smith was recorded on the Bulleen farm in the early 1890s.(30)  This 1894 house was later identified as Ben Nevis.

The Ben Nevis property covered 200 acres in the 1895 Shire of Templestowe rate book. The property was still owned and occupied by George Smith.(31) A substantial house was recorded there during this decade. The valuation on Smith's house and land increased from 365 pounds to 465 pounds between 1896 and 1897.(32)

In 1938, the Ben Nevis property was transferred from John, Thomas and Robert Smith, dairymen, to Thomas Stewart, George Samuel and Daniel White, Kew dairymen, trading as M. J. White and Sons. At this time, Ben Nevis was described as house and sheds on 299 acres of land between Bulleen and Thompson Roads.(33) A recent MMBW Property Sewerage Plan shows alterations made to the large double-story house by the White family during their ownership.(34)

Of local historical significance for its associations from the 1890s with early district dairy farmer, George Smith Sen., and from the 1930s with the White family of Kew, dairymen.

(28) Shire of Bulleen RB 1889-90 No.124 (NAV 188 pounds)
(29) Parish of Bulleen, 1906; Plan of the Farm Subdivision of the Carlton Estate, R.G.Bagot, c.1850.
(30) Shire of Bulleen RB 1894 Templestowe Riding No.134 (Then owned by the Chatsworth Estate Co., a land company owned by the land boomer, James Munro).
(31) Shire of Bulleen RB 1895 Templestowe Riding No.132. 
(32) Shire of Bulleen RB 1897 Templestowe Riding No.135.
(33) Shire of Doncaster and Templestowe RB 1938-39 Templestowe Riding Nos. 834,835 and 836. 
(34) MMBW Property Sewerage Plan No. 554648, 1 May 1977- 18 Aug.1982. 

Source: Doncaster and Templestowe Heritage Study - Additional Historical Research Pg11
http://images.heritage.vic.gov.au/attachment/3868



Ben Nevis House c1940


Ben Nevis House c2015



Ben Nevis: two-storied house near the corner of Bulleen and Thompsons Roads, Bulleen, built for George Smith about 1890. The house still stands today in what is now Ben Nevis Court and is to be auctioned on 20 march 1999 for an estimated price of one million dollars. It now stands in one acre of grounds whereas years ago it was on a dairy farm of hundreds of acres. It is now situated next to the Sentimental Bloke Hotel.    DP0393


Ben Nevis:  Front corner at Thompsons and Bulleen Roads, Bulleen, showing the extensive use of lacework around the verandahs and polychrome brickwork. There are three men, two women and two dogs on the lawn. The elderly gentleman is probably George Smith who had the house built about 1890. The elderly lady seated next to him is probably his wife, formerly Miss Duncan, a daughter of Alexander Duncan, one of the earliest settlers in the area. The house is now in Ben Nevis Court, Bulleen. DP0394


Ben Nevis

This lovely old home was built in 1890 by George Smith, a member of a notable Templestowe and Bulleen family in the late nineteenth century.

George had arrived from Inverness, Scotland in 1853-54 as a young man.. He purchased land near the Duncan family in Bulleen, later marrying one of the daughters of Alexander Duncan. Possibly George Smith had first settled near the present Camberwell Golf Links, but later, bought the land from William Clarke, Joseph Clarke, and Patric McCaughan, directors of the Chatsworth Estate Company.

He became a most successful dairy farmer in the area and urged other members of his family to emigrate from Scotland. The Smith brothers, Tom, David, John, James, and Joseph played an important role in many aspects of the developing Shire of Bulleen, proclaimed on 7th May 1875.

They also were deeply involved with the Templestowe Cemetery Trust, and there is an Avenue within the cemetery, dedicated to the Smith family in appreciation of their devoted work over a long period.

Ben Nevis, built by George Smith in 1890. Standing on the hill above the Sentimental Bloke Hotel.

Named after "Ben Nevis", the tallest mountain in Scotland, the home stands on the highest point of the Smith land, to avoid the flooding which frequently occurred when the Yarra River broke its banks.

The house was a typical Victorian style of stately proportions with verandas extending around the front and side.

These were originally built with wooden floors, ornate cast iron lace and an iron roof. Due to deterioration and loose railings the verandas were demolished and the terraces paved with concrete. In the 1980's, the verandah with its cast iron lace has been replaced.

The interior has seen some alteration. Many homesteads in the nineteenth century, were the focal point of a farm and were used not only by the family in residence, but by farm workers. "Ben Nevis" had a large mess room on the ground floor once used by farm labourers for eating and there was a downstairs bedroom for a servant.

Alterations have included a functional kitchen, adjacent dining room with a sun room and laundry which makes the house more suitable for modem living.

As the only bedrooms for the family were upstairs, the new owners, converted downstairs sitting areas into extra bedrooms.

The small windows, typical of many homes built in the 1890"s did not fit in with the modem desire for airiness and light, so new windows have been added. Many of these are floor to ceiling style, to combat the dark interiors.

Ben Nevis, built by George Smith in 1890. Standing on the hill above the Sentimental Bloke Hotel.

As "Ben Nevis" was not connected to electricity, modem alterations have included attractive light fittings, hung from the original ornate rose mouldings.

Marble fireplaces were closed off and some were remodelled to suit modern tastes. As time has passed, the original 200 acres has been reduced to about one acre. Land which was originally part of the farm estate is now occupied by Marcellin College, Carey Grammar, a golf course, parks and the Sentimental Bloke Hotel.

"Ben Nevis" still stands in a prominent place on the hillside and remains a neighbourhood landmark, taking its place among the grand homes of Bulleen.

Source: Bulleen - A Short History (1991). By Judith Leaney.   Illustrated by Irvine Green


Glimpses of Ben Nevis


Our October speaker, George Collins, is the great grandson of George Smith who built the grand old house, still existing on the hill, near Bulleen Road, in 1890.
George Smith arrived in Australia at the age of 24 in 1853/54 and first settled on the site of the Camberwell Golf Links. He later purchased land near the Duncan family who were very early settlers in Bulleen, and in 1863, married Isabella Duncan, one of the Duncan daughters.
The rest of George’s family, parents John and Elizabeth and his brothers followed him out to Australia, from Inverness in 1857.
Between them, the Smith family played a major role in the development of Templestowe and Bulleen being involved in the Cemetery Trust, Local Council and Church.
George was a well known dairy farmer in the district and won prizes for his cheese at the Melbourne Exhibition in 1881.
“Ben Nevis” has been altered over the years to accommodate changes in taste and levels of comfort expected in modem times.
Our speaker, George Collins, who visited the old house and farm in the 1930’$ described the layout at that time. Downstairs, each side of a central passage were a kitchen, dining room and lounge. Originally the servants’ bedroom was the only one downstairs. All the other bedrooms were upstairs. A large mess room, used earlier by workers on the farm was altered to accommodate a rear staircase, laundry and sunroom.
Even in the 1930’s there was no electric light in the house and no running water. A well outside was used for obtaining water. George helped with the general farm work, enjoying his time riding on a horse around the farm, rounding up the cows for milking. There was a 60 bale cowshed, and our society possesses a photo with the black and white cows grazing in the fields with the lovely old house forming a background. The original land was over 200 acres and the driveway entrance extended right to Thompson’s Road. In the 1930’$ there were billabongs on the farmland and George remembers that the 1934 flood waters inundated the whole area.
Later in 1939, the land was sold to Mr and Mrs White • who altered much of the house to suit modem requirements.
In the 1960’s most of the land was subdivided and “Ben Nevis” retained only one acre surrounding the house. Present day occupants of the original land are Marcellin College, Carey Grammar, recreation parks and the Manningham Club.
We were privileged to hear some original anecdotes of activities on the farm from George, and ancestor of the Smiths, bringing the story to life and giving it a personality of its own.

Source: George Collins reported in the 2010-03 DTHS Newsletter



Exact Location:  ???

Mrs Isabella Duncan wife of Alexander Duncan, in the front garden of her wattle and daub house near the intersection of Bulleen Road and Thompsons Road at Bulleen. Alexander and Isabella settled in Bulleen in or about the year 1847 and leased one of the farms on the Carlton Estate. DP0664



Deaths - DUNCAN

On the 13th October, at her residence, Bulleen, Isabel, relict of the late Alexander Duncan, formerly of Melrose, Scotland, only daughter of the late James Ramsay, Southbridge, Edinburgh, the dearly loved mother of Willie, John, and Kate Duncan, and Mrs. George Smith, Bulleen, aged 88 years and 4 months. By special request, no flowers.

Source: 1902 'Family Notices', The Argus (Melbourne, Vic. : 1848 - 1957), 15 October, p. 1. , viewed 22 Feb 2018, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article9080802


On the 13th inst. a very old colonist, Mrs. Isabel Duncan, of Bulleen, died at the age of 88 years. She arrived in Victoria in November, 1839, with her husband, the late Mr. Alexander Duncan, who died some 45 years ago. Mr. and Mrs. Duncan lived for some time in a tent at Gardiner's Creek, and afterwards settled at Bulleen, beyond Kew. The first Presbyterian congregation in that district used to meet in Mr Duncan's barn, where the pews were boards supported by bags of grain; the pulpit desk was a churn covered by a tablecloth; and the baptismal font was a china basin. There was a monthly service, conducted by the Rev. Mr. Forbes, who was the first Presbyterian minister resident in Melbourne. Of Mrs. Duncan's large family there survive two daughters, Mrs. George Smith and Miss Kate Duncan, of Bulleen, and two sons, Mr. William Duncan, who is in New South Wales, and Mr. John Duncan, of Clifton Hill. There are also 26 grandchildren and 5 great grandchildren.

Source: 1902 'DEATH OF AN OLD COLONIST.', Albury Banner and Wodonga Express (NSW : 1896 - 1938), 31 October, p. 29. , viewed 22 Feb 2018, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article100614896

Obituary - Mrs Isabel Duncan

And [sic] old and well-beloved resident of the Bulleen district passed away on the 13th October, Mrs Isabel Duncan, who had been a widow upwards of 45 years. She and her husband, the late Mr Alex. Duncan, who was for several years in partnership with Mr Robert Laidlaw, of " Springbank," Heidelberg, arrived in Victoria in November 1839, by the ship, " Palmyra." They moved out to Gardiner's Creek, where their residence was a tent, and subsequently settled in Bulleen. As a girl Mrs Duncan (Isabel Ramsey) lived at Melrose and had many pleasurable recollections of the old Abbey, which were revived for her after 60 years by the gift of a book of views of Melrose Abbey brought to her by the Rev D. Fraser after his last trip to Britain. In the early forties the Rev Mr Forbes, who had come to Melbourne in January 1839, held Presbyterian Church service in Mr Duncan's barn among rural surroundings, the pulpit being the space behind a large churn covered with the best tablecloth, and the pews improvised of boards supported on bags filled with grain. A precious family relic was a basin of fine china from which Mrs Duncan had been baptized in infancy, and this formed the font in the barn church. Mrs Duncan had entered on her 89th year when she died, but her eyesight was excellent to the last. Great numbers of caps, socks and cushions were made by her and her daughter and sent off to the soldiers fighting in South Africa. She leaves behind the memory of what a consistent Christian life should be and her children have cause to bless her memory. Those of her family who survive are Mrs George Smith and Miss Kate Duncan of Bulleen, Mr Wm. Duncan of N.S.W., and Mr John Duncan of Clifton Hill, also 26 grandchildren and 5 great grandchildren.

Source: 1902 'OBITUARY.', Evelyn Observer and Bourke East Record (Vic. : 1902 - 1917), 31 October, p. 1. (MORNING.), viewed 22 Feb 2018, http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article60623870



The newly immigrated Duncan family moved to Toorak Road, South Yarra where Alexander had purchased a small piece of land, built a house and where Isabella conducted a private school. 

She advertised in the Melbourne newspapers for students. 

Ken has more information about Alexander and Isabella derived from notes taken from early Melbourne newspapers. He will bring them on Saturday to the general meeting, and if I am unable to attend (I’m off to Broome for 2 weeks on Sunday), she can take photos of same and forward this information to me (then me onto you).




Isabella Duncan


Mrs Isabella Duncan wife of Alexander Duncan, in the front garden of her wattle and daub house near the intersection of Bulleen Road and Thompsons Road at Bulleen. Alexander and Isabella settled in Bulleen in or about the year 1847 and leased one of the farms on the Carlton Estate. DP0664, DP0395)


From a comfortable mansion on a large Scottish estate to a mud hut on 'the banks of the Yarra, was a dramatic change in living conditions. Isabella Duncan was able to cope with this change for she was a woman of spirit and determination. Three years earlier she had defied her wealthy parents and married a groom from the family stables, Alexander Duncan. In 1839, the couple, now reconciled with her parents, left for Australia with a party of Scottish immigrants. Isabella, her husband Alexander and their two children sailed on the ship "Midlothian" arriving in Melbourne in June that year.

Isabella gained her first experience of Melbourne from a tent in Collins Street where she lived for a month just above the site of the present City Square, but it was then still bushland. The next year Isabella was in her own home, a wattle and daube hut alongside Koonung Creek near where it enters the Yarra. Isabella, Alexander and the girls shared the hut with two other men, a youth and a young girl. Her piano and a few pieces of furniture from Scotland, decorated the rooms and an oil painting of Isabella hung on the wall.

They lived on the rich river flats at Bulleen. The grassland was dotted with a few magnificent, spreading red gum trees and chains of lagoons broke up the ground. The largest was called Lake Bulleen, a large area of water surrounded by thick reeds that were almost impenetrable. The lagoons teemed with fish, and water birds filled the air with their wild cries.

While Isabella learnt to be a farmers wife, growing vegetables, making butter and bread and keeping chooks, Alexander helped his partners drain the swamps, plough the land, and plant wheat and barley. The youth spent the day watching the cows, for in the first years there were no fences to hold the cattle and protect the crops. Some years later a bull broke through a fence, escaping into the bush. The bull was not lost but continually evaded capture. For many years the determined animal forced its way into Laidlaw's paddocks or into Duncan’s pasture to mate cows.

Several fellow passengers from the “Midlothian” had settled in Bulleen and across the river in Heidelberg. In response to a call from these men, Rev. Peter Gunn, a Presbyterian minister came to Bulleen to hold a church service in December, 1843. Isabella and Alexander offered their barn for the service. A butter churn was used as a reading table and the congregation sat on planks laid across bags of wheat.

During the 1840‘s the fertile river flats were covered with acres of wheat and barley. At harvest time the fields of golden grain were a picturesque sight. Isabella and her eldest daughter were out in the fields following the reapers as they moved across the crop, swinging scythes in a steady rhythm. The girls helped gather the fallen corn, tying the sheaths and stacking the stooks in rows across the empty stubble.
Isabella’s eldest son, James, was born soon after arriving in Bulleen. In the following years she had more children, her family increasing to 4 boys and 5 girls, but she kept up the standards she had been used to in Scotland. Sunday was the Sabbath, when they put on their best clothes and washed and dressed the children carefully. Before Sunday dinner, cooked over the open fire, family prayers were held, and in .the afternoon, Alexander was asked to read from the Bible. Then hymns were sung as Isabella played the piano. She was a well-educated woman who played very well. It was a “square piano” and looked something like a flat box on legs, with a keyboard on the front. Isabella taught her children to read and write and do sums, holding regular classes. Soon other families sent their children to the house to join the children during their classes. So Isabella became the first “school teacher” in the district.

In 1857 Alexander Duncan died. James now a sixteen year old boy, took over the responsibility for the dairy farm. Continuous flooding along the river flats often ruined crops so their ninety four acres were now all turned to grass and the dairy herd enlarged, A new barn and cheese factory was built on higher ground in Thompsons Road. In 1863, after days of steady rain, the creek and the river flooded. Every day the water rose higher, flooding Isabella’s house till only the roof showed above the water. The Yarra flats were like a sea that stretched away into the distance. Isabella and her children went with a neighbour to shelter in an empty house on dry land. Gradually the water receded and as the level fell, water swirled out of the door of their home, carrying with it Isabella’s piano. It floated out the door and down the creek finally coming to rest against a submerged log.

Isabella’s eldest daughter, also called Isabella, married a fellow countryman and neighbour, George Smith. They extended their dairy farm by purchasing her mother’s farm and in 1890 built a two story mansion on the hill overlooking their new land. With nostalgic memories of their home country, they called their new home “Ben Nevis”’.

When the immigrants who came to Australia, left their home land, they dreamt of making a fortune in the new country,. Many were sadly disappointed, but those, such as Isabella Duncan’s daughter, who did succeed, wished to display their new wealth in the tangible form of bricks and mortar.

Source: Extract from: Green, Irvine. & Doncaster-Templestowe Historical Society.  1987,  Petticoats in the orchard / Irvine Green  Doncaster-Templestowe Historical Society, 81 McGowans Road Donvale Vic. 3111, Vic  Illustrated By Irvine Green.  ISBN: 0950092096. NLA https://catalogue.nla.gov.au/Record/1453230.     Original Format PDF